NOTE
This website was created to educate Maine voters ahead of the 2018 District Attorney elections. It is not being updated for 2022.
What is a da
District attorneys are some of the most powerful people in the criminal justice system. As government prosecutors, they make key decisions in criminal cases about who gets charged, what they get charged with, and the ultimate punishments they face. DAs are elected officials. They answer to you.
Why you should care
District attorneys make decisions that impact all of us. Their views on criminal justice policy set the tone for how our communities respond to societal issues and have great influence on the police and Legislature.
Transparency & Accountability
As elected officials, DAs are accountable to us. They have an obligation to increase transparency by meeting with community members and publicly sharing information about how their office operates.
Public Health
DAs help decide whether people with substance use disorders and other mental illness go to jail, or get access to more effective solutions like community-based treatment.
Equal Treatment
DAs have the power to insist that people are treated fairly in everything from charging, to trial, to sentencing - regardless of race, disability, gender, sexual orientation or other factors.
Youth
Children don’t belong in prison, and DAs can support community-based alternatives that help young people thrive, keep communities and families involved, and cost taxpayers less.
Mass Incarceration
The US has the highest incarceration rate in the world. DAs can fix that with fair charging and sentencing, and by championing alternatives to prison like diversion and treatment programs.
Poverty
A person’s income shouldn’t determine their fate in the justice system. DAs make decisions about whether people will be stuck in jail because they can’t afford bail or they can’t pay their fines.
1
2
3
4
5
6
MEET MAINE'S DAs.
There are eight prosecutorial districts in Maine, each with an elected district attorney. Find out where your DA stands on key criminal justice issues.
All candidates for DA were sent a questionnaire before the November 2018 election and invited to respond.
Select County
MEET MAINE'S DAs.
for district attorney in
.
Select two candidates to compare their views on key criminal justice policy
Select two candidates to compare their views on key criminal justice policy
Todd Collins
Democrat - DID NOT RETURN SURVEY
Matthew Foster
Republican DID NOT RETURN SURVEY
Marianne Lynch
Republican DID NOT RETURN SURVEY
Maeghan Maloney
Democrat DID NOT RETURN SURVEY
Andrew Robinson
Democrat DID NOT RETURN SURVEY
Kathryn Slattery
Democrat DID NOT RETURN SURVEY
Candidate views on
Select Candidate
Select Candidate
Do you agree with the 91 percent of Americans who say that the criminal justice system has problems that need fixing? If yes, what are your top three priorities to fix?
Will you make policies of the District Attorney’s Office publicly available on the office’s website unless mandated as confidential by law or otherwise legally prohibited?
For data that you are already mandated to collect, will you commit to publicly posting statistical information on charging decisions, convictions, declinations, and diversion program placements – disaggregated by race and gender?
If the District Attorney’s office is not already collecting the data mentioned above, will you pledge to create a plan for collecting and publicizing that data?
Would you ask the Attorney General to appoint an independent prosecutor in all officer-involved shootings?
Would you commit to strengthening or initiating community outreach programs in your office and to engage and communicate with all constituencies in your district, including indigenous communities, communities of color, the LGBT community, immigrant communities, community-based organizations, and criminal justice reform advocates, in addition to groups representing the faith community, victims, seniors, and businesses?
Do you support sending young offenders to restorative justice and other pre-adjudication diversion programs?
Recognizing that children and youth are categorically less culpable than adults and that they have less impulse control, will you commit to not seek to bind juveniles over as adults? If “no,” explain why not?
Would you advocate to the Department of Corrections for a shift in budgetary priorities from incarceration to a continuum of community-based alternatives for at-risk and system-involved youth?
Do you support closing the Long Creek youth facility in favor of more effective alternatives that don’t cause harm? If no, why?
Would you ensure that no child is incarcerated solely for “their own safety” or rehabilitation?
Will you recommend, for all legally permissible cases, the pretrial release of defendants without imposing cash bail unless there is an individualized showing of substantial flight risk or danger to the community?
Alaska and New Jersey have eliminated cash bail and in each state it’s expected to significantly reduce the prison population and save millions of dollars. Would you support legislation to eliminate cash bail at the state level as a condition of pretrial release?
Do you support correlating bail amounts to defendants’ financial resources so as to reduce disproportionate impacts on the poor?
Would you work with businesses in your district to find alternatives to arresting and prosecuting so called “quality of life” offenses that do not genuinely threaten communities, such as camping and sleeping in cars?
Would you encourage police departments in your district to issue summonses rather than arrest people for most Class D and E (misdemeanor) crimes?
Is there existing policy in your District on when the Office asks for fines or restitution other than what is statutorily mandated? If yes, would you make it publicly available? If no, would you create and publicize one?
Would you commit to diverting people with mental health disorders away from jails when there is a community-based or alternative treatment available that does not involve incarceration?
Do you commit to working to expand the treatment programs available for people with mental health issues, including asking legislators for appropriations and working with communities?
Maine faces an ongoing opioid crisis. Will you support legislation and administrative approaches to treat opiate addiction as a disease rather than a crime so we can divest from the criminal justice approach and invest in treatment and education?
Will you support legislation to divert people with substance use disorders away from our jails and into community-based or alternative treatment, like the Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) program?
Will you support legislation and administrative approaches aimed at reducing racial bias in Maine’s criminal justice system?
Will you commit to tracking and working to eliminate racial disparities in decisions made by the district attorney’s office, such as disparities in charging decisions, bail recommendations, and plea bargains?
Will you commit to requiring that assistant district attorneys participate in racial equity and bias training to reduce the influence of race on decisions made by the District Attorney’s office?
Do you pledge to set a goal and work to reduce the number of people under correctional control in your District by 2022?
Will you commit to the following in order to reduce the number of people under correctional control in your District: Charging the lowest level crime that still promotes public safety.
Will you commit to the following in order to reduce the number of people under correctional control in your District: Only charging crimes that the evidence clearly supports (i.e., not overcharging).
Will you commit to the following in order to reduce the number of people under correctional control in your District: Recommending rehabilitative or other diversionary programs instead of incarceration unless required for public safety.
Do you oppose the creation of new mandatory minimum sentences?
Will you pledge to adopt a written policy and training which encourages prosecutors to consider the immigration-related consequences of prosecutorial decisions at all stages of a case and to reach immigration-safe dispositions for non-citizens whenever possible?
Do you support limiting conditions of release to addressing actual threats to the public?
People are often subjected to conditions of release that are already prohibitions under criminal law, such as driving with a suspended license or using illegal drugs. Would you support eliminating such duplicative conditions?
Would you advocate to police departments in your district to minimize custodial arrest for violations of conditions of release?
Would you commit to not recommend random searches (suspicion-less search) as a condition of release?
Learn + take action
Join Community
Get updates on key issues and events. By clicking subscribe you agree to receive emails from the ACLU.
We'll never share your email with anyone else.
The ACLU of Maine is a non-partisan 501(c)(4) organization and does not endorse or oppose candidates for political office. We advocate for a fair justice system that fosters public safety while reducing the number of people behind bars. This website features current district attorneys' responses to our District Attorney Questionnaire. All DA candidates in the state were sent a questionnaire prior to the November 2018 election and invited to respond.